How Much Is An Online Degree Worth?
Employment News March 22nd, 2006Keep up to date on articles and news and subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!
How Much Is An Online Degree Worth?
In a time not so long ago, online degrees were questionable, frowned upon, even considered worthless. Could someone really sit at home, stare at a screen, and learn as much as someone sitting in a classroom?
Many educators doubted it. It seemed the lazy man’s way of learning. But new research suggests that stigma is not only fading, but transforming into eLearning accolades. Recently, an in-depth study from Sloan Consortium, a group supporting online education, confirmed what advocates of cyber-academics had been saying for years: Online learning can be just as good as — if not better than — a classroom degree.
“A majority of academic leaders (57 percent) believe learning outcomes for online education are equal to or superior to those of face-to-face instruction,” proclaims the Sloan study.
One of those academic leaders — James Sherwood, Ph.D., dean of University Extension, the continuing education branch of The University of California at Berkeley — elaborates. “Coming out of World War II and getting into the ’60s and ’70s, there was a kind of stigma associated with distance education. That has certainly changed,” says Sherwood. “Because of video streaming, chat rooms, and all the other kinds of technological advances, traditional faculty is becoming more comfortable.”
Both Sides of the Coin
Dr. Michael Otaigbe has had the unique chance to compare both types of learning. A classroom professor for 15 years, Otaigbe began teaching online two years ago through Strayer University. And, this semester, he’s teaching the same course — Sociology of Comparative Religions — both online and in a classroom at Strayer’s Woodbridge, Va., campus.
Though he initially struggled to adjust to not having face-to-face time with his students, he has found that his online class generates a level of motivation he hadn’t expected.
“Online, I have the freedom to require contributions. Every week, my students have to submit essays and participate in group discussions,” Otaigbe says. “I get a better sense of the learning process.”
Whereas in a classroom setting, students must respond instantly during discussions, he explains, the online students have more time to research an answer and reflect on what to say before posting a response.
“In fact, what I have learned from the online class, I have used to improve my class teaching,” Otaigbe says.
Otaigbe has also found inspiration from his online students, some of whom — unlike his classroom students — come from all over the world, which benefits the other online students as well.
“I have students from Japan, from China,” says Otaigbe. “I know my student from India contributed a lot when we were talking about Hinduism.”
Recruiter’s Perspective
The online degree may get respect from educators now, but that’s not enough if the rest of the world doesn’t follow suit. In some ways, a degree is only as good as the opportunities it affords. Fortunately, recruiters have already begun to recognize the value of an online degree, says John Dooney, manager of strategic research for the Society for Human Resource Management, an association of HR professionals.
“Typically, a person with an online degree is someone who is also working in an organization, so they have experience,” says Dooney. “You’re getting someone who has the total package.”
Formerly an employment manager for 15 years, Dooney admits that online degrees weren’t always looked upon positively. “Ten years ago, people just weren’t sure,” Dooney says. “But now, I don’t think people say ‘Oh, they’re not working hard.’”
As corporations have started using distance learning in their continuing education offerings, it has become more and more accepted as a way to earn a degree as well, he says. Sherwood, who has 20 years of experience running distance learning programs, however, does caution that not all programs are equal.
“One factor is the institution itself,” Sherwood says. “If the institution offers on-site degrees and those degrees aren’t worth anything, then obviously their distance degrees aren’t either.” He also advises a level examination of an academic discipline. “Some fields lend themselves to distance education, and some are more difficult to do at a distance.” For example, advanced degrees with a serious lab work component might be a struggle to complete through an exclusively online format, he says.
As online learning continues to evolve into a well-respected educational option, perhaps the Sloan Consortium was on to something when it stated that almost one-third of academic leaders “expect that learning outcomes for online education will be superior to face-to-face instruction in three years.” Perhaps your online degree will be worth even more than you think!
August 28th, 2006 at 6:59 am
Online Diplomas are Trash
Although members of the media and some academicians have been saying that online instruction is the wave of the future, one simple fact remains: Online schools provide a second-rate education and diplomas from online institutions are essentially trash.
Until the summer of 2006, I was associated with a university that maintained a large online division in northern Virginia plus 43 satellite campuses in 10 southeastern states and the District of Columbia. For approximately five years I taught online business courses in both synchronous and asynchronous modes. To my chagrin, I discovered the following:
• The school has no library to speak of. It maintains various “Learning Resource Centers” that collectively have 27,000 volumes or one book for each of the estimated 27,000 students who study online or at satellite campuses. Indiana University’s library system, in contrast, has 8.2 million volumes.
• Quizzes and exams are online, open-book and unproctored. Students routinely enlist others to help them at exam time.
• There is pressure on instructors to give high grades and thereby maintain full-time equivalent (FTE) enrollment numbers. Instructors who have the temerity to give grades of C or D are called in for counseling.
• Students never meet or have direct contact with instructors.
• The school has an open-enrollment policy which encourages unqualified or marginally qualified applicants. Nevertheless, approximately one-third of all students graduate with “honors.”
Incredibly, this institution is accredited by the Middle States Commission on Higher Education.
Gary Jacobsen, B.S., M.B.A
Member, American Association of University Professors
January 29th, 2007 at 11:22 am
Online programs give many the people the chance to go back to school; a chance they wouldn’t have due to chronic illness, the inability to commute to a campus (be it time or distance constraints), and having familial obligations. Online academic programs give more options to more people.
Degree mills capitalize on the ignorance of others, and tarnish the images of legitimate schools and their programs. It is a student’s duty to ask the important questions about the quality of an academic program and about the institution’s credentials. Unfortunately, too many people jump into an online program without giving it enough thought and without comparing different institutions.
August 13th, 2007 at 8:58 am
I will never go to a classroom again. I have almost finished my BS degree From the University of Tennessee. It was more challenging and you get to interact will people from all over. In a classroom, I was always stereotyped and teachers were not friendly. I am a black male with Computer Certifications and 20 years work experience and I am able to learn in the comfort of my own home and also help other students and the teachers. I highly recommend on-line learning. I made my son stop going to class and take on line. He enjoys it. We read more books, read all the discussions and really get energy from interacting with the other students.